This post is inspired by all of the re-evaluations I have to do this year and the ones I have already gotten done.

At my school, I test the majority of the students with the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals- 4th Edition (CELF-4). It was the test that I used for the majority of graduate school and the only multi-topic one that I have on hand at my school. (I have to borrow everything else from the other SLPs). Needless to say, I have a pretty good relationship now with this test. I really loved this assessment tool when I first started out. It covers syntax, following directions, retell, and pragmatics to hit the high points. My feelings towards the test have dampened a little over time as I've come to realize how much of an emphasis it places on syntax. It is not easy for students from lower socio-economic statuses or English as a Second Language to do well on this assessment. Granted, the test isn't supposed to be easy per say...but it really makes some of the kids frustrated. The students I test are so stressed about every test they take and I feel really bad for them as the tasks get increasing harder. I usually give them "brain breaks" to help ease some of the tension.
So, I decided to give the Comprehensive Assessment of Spoken Language a try during my most recent re-evaluation.
I really like the larger variety of subtests that it offers and the flexibility. It is still going to challenge students but I think the variety lessens some of the frustration. My student also seemed more confident than many of the ones who endure the CELF-4. The
easy chart that tells you what to do for each age group is a life saver:
Age |
3-0 to
4-11
|
5-0 to
6-11
|
7-0 to
10-11
|
11-0 to
12-11
|
13-0 to
17-11
|
18-0 to
21-11
|
Comprehension of Basic Concepts | C | S | | | | |
Antonyms | | C | C | C | S | S |
Synonyms | | | S | S | C | C |
Sentence Completion | S | S | S | S | S | S |
Idiomatic Language | | | | S | S | S |
Syntax Construction | C | C | C | S | S | S |
Paragraph Comprehension of Syntax | S | C | C | S | | |
Grammatical Morphemes | | | S | C | S | S |
Sentence Comprehension of Syntax | | | | C | S | S |
Grammaticality Judgment | | | S | S | C | C |
Nonliteral Language | | | C | C | C | C |
Meaning from Context | | | | S | C | C |
Inference | | | S | S | S | |
Ambiguous Sentences | | | | S | S | S |
Pragmatic Judgment | C | C | C | C | C | C |
The hardest part of this test was figuring out the scoring manual. I got really confused with the layout of the scores and had to re-score it after consulting with the other SLPs in my district. That's definitely my biggest complaint with it.
I'm pretty sure I will be experimenting more with the CASL in the months to come. It's always good to open yourself to new tools.